Honestly, this felt like a big disappointment after the other two - especially right after the Molé Merkin. In comparison, there was a bit of a vegetal weirdness to the flavor here. It evened out after the palate adjusted, and it's hard to argue the easy appeal of sweet, but it definitely colored my experience.

Still a superb beer. Not profound, I think its lightness prevents that, but so, so smoooooth.

I’ll just add what Mr T said here because he so rarely gives a description: “Mmmmmmm. Smells like something worn many, many times by a lady of the night.” “I can smell the arthropods.” “Are you trying to get me drunk?”

Very smooth. Chocolate, caramel, roasted flavors.

Tasty. So tasty it'd be worth walking a block over to a friend's place to drink.

Beeeeeeeeers

Pretty good oatmeal stout. A little light though. Boozy, fruity, very slight carbonation.

This one seems to produce a nicer head than others, Also has a lighter smell and less emphasis on molasses flavors, It's more roasty, I'd say it even present some burnt/ashes flavors in the aftertaste. It's overall drier than the others. Also getting a very light sourness.

Super delicious

Just a few degrees below room temperature seems ideal for serving this beer. Chocolatey and smooth, with a really nice, complex but smooth malt-ball texture. Delicious.

It was great, One more Please :)

Smooth with a great depth of flavor from the aging. More of a fortified-wine-aged flavor than a bourbon one though.

There wasn't a lot left in the bottle, but what I could squeeze out of it tasted great.

It was awesome, smooth and I would like one more please.

Had this with a stew tonight. Really good match. I liked it better than what I remembered!

Ok, i'm giving this a high rating for two reasons: first, it tasted like liquified flourless chocolate cake, which is the best cake because it's rich and chocolatey and fatty without all of that useless flour-poison that Gwyneth Paltrow tells me I shouldn't eat if I want to look emaciated like her. Second, because on a Saturday night when Xbox One has ONCE AGAIN ruined date night this was like a platonic chocolate and alcohol hug. Some girls just eat Ben and Jerry's straight out of the container...

A bit of a metallic taste and less than ideal texture from the carbon knock this down a point.

Fermented prune smell. Sweetish oatmeal taste with some raisin qualities. Complexity to flavor so you're not left searching for more but also not overdone.

A thin-mouthfeel but still somehow creamy oatmeal stout with a sweet bourbon finish. It's not ... profound in the same way as other boxed Firestone releases, but it's extremely delicious and deceptively drinkable.