I gave this a 5.5 for 2 reasons. First, it is redolent of coconut, and since I am 1/8 Hawaiian it made my cells start to do a little hula dance (haole's call this getting a "buzz". Whatever). Second, I am drinking this on my birthday and everything, even the wilted salad I had for lunch, tastes better today. Also, it is a rich, sweet, syrupy yet complex beer, if you give it the time to play a little on the tongue. Good thing we bough two, even though it meant we had to take out a second mortgage on our house...